特朗普将 AI 生存风险斥为骗局

Trump Goes Full Hoax on AI Existential Risk

兹维·莫绍维茨 Zvi Mowshowitz · Don't Worry About the Vase · 2026-09-16 · Don't Worry About the Vase ↗

打开互动全文版(逐段中英对照 + 针对本篇提问)→

摘要 · Abstract

文章认为,特朗普总统将 AI 生存风险斥为骗局,作者将这一说法主要归因于黄仁勋(Nvidia CEO)和 David Sacks 等人的误导性简报,这些人的商业利益与淡化 AI 危险相一致。文章主张,特朗普的言论把对数据中心的担忧与对灾难性 AI 风险的警告混为一谈,而他反复变化的立场使局势悬而未决、仍有变数。作者坚持认为,AI 末日论者是真诚的,把他们的警告称为骗局在事实上是错误的,而像黄仁勋这样玩世不恭的行为者正积极把政策推向悬崖。文章呼吁读者不要以党派立场或个人攻击回应特朗普或共和党人,因为那样只会让结果更糟,而应提升跨政治光谱中有益的声音。结论是:局势并非已成定局,特朗普的立场可能再次转变,当务之急是避免让事情变得更糟,同时继续点名批评那些具体的恶意行为者。

The article argues that President Trump has dismissed AI existential risk as a hoax, a claim the author attributes largely to misleading briefings from figures such as Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang and David Sacks, whose commercial interests align with downplaying AI dangers. It contends that Trump's rhetoric conflates concerns about data centers with warnings about catastrophic AI risk, and that his shifting positions leave the situation unsettled and open to change. The author maintains that AI doomers are sincere, that calling their warnings a hoax is factually wrong, and that cynical actors like Huang are actively driving policy off a cliff. Readers are urged not to respond with partisan or personal attacks on Trump or Republicans, since doing so would only worsen the outcome, and instead to elevate helpful voices across the political spectrum. The conclusion is that the situation is not fixed, that Trump's stance could shift again, and that the priority is to avoid making things worse while continuing to call out specific bad-faith actors.

核心贡献 · Key contributions

局限 · Limitations

章节 · Sections(共 24)

全文 · Full text(逐段中英对照)

目录 Table of Contents

5. 总统先生,这与数据中心无关。

5. This Is Not About Data Centers, Mr. President.

6. 我是骗局揭穿者,我是骗局揭穿者,我是海象。

6. I Am The Hoax Buster, I Am The Hoax Buster, I Am The Walrus.

7. Nvidia CEO 黄仁勋是个彻头彻尾的骗子。

7. Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang Is a Lying Liar.

8. 特朗普悄然划出关键区分。

8. Trump Quietly Draws Key Distinction.

9. 呼吁放缓前沿模型发展对 AI 股价不利。

9. Calling For Pacing the Frontier Is Bad For AI Stock Prices.

10. 互联网上的人有时会说谎。

10. People on the Internet Sometimes Lie.

13. 麦卡锡主义派系攻击 METR。

13. The McCarthyist Faction Attacks METR.

15. David Sacks 不再显得具有建设性。

15. David Sacks Stops Being Plausibly Constructive.

16. 联邦贸易委员会选择危险。

16. Federal Trade Commission Chooses Danger.

21. 如果你如此迫切地想击败中国,你就应该拿出相应的行动。

21. If You Want to Beat China So Badly, You Should Act Like It.

保持克制 Hold Your Fire

在事态发展的过程中,最重要的一点始终是不要把事情弄得更糟。

The most important thing, as this plays out, remains to not make things worse.

请不要让这件事比现在更加党派化或人身化。请不要攻击共和党人或特朗普。那只会让事情变得更糟。要强调各方有益的声音。

Please do not make this any more partisan or personal than it already is. Please do not attack Republicans, or Trump. That will only make things worse. Emphasize helpful voices on all sides.

这并不意味着你不能指出错误帖子就是错的,也不能指出某些特定的人是在恶意行事,或以特定方式撒谎。当然,你可以点名像 Jensen 和 Sacks 这类惯常人物,他们正在积极地把我们推向悬崖。

That does not mean you do not point out that Wrong Post is Wrong, or that particular people are in bad faith or are lying in particular ways. Certainly you can call out the Usual Suspects like Jensen and Sacks who are actively driving us off a cliff.

你所不能做的,是把共和党人作为一个群体来攻击,或从方方面面人身攻击特朗普——而你们中的许多人会极想这么做。

What you do not do is go after Republicans as a group, or attack Trump personally in all the ways many of you will be sorely tempted to do.

出于同样的原因,为避免强化党派化的框架,我将不收录民主党政治人物的相关言论。

For the same reason, to avoid reinforcing a partisan frame, I will refrain from including related statements from Democratic politicians.

若你不喜欢这天气 If You Don’t Like the Weather

在我们深入细节之前,我还要强调:这里没有任何事情是固定不变的。

Before we get into details, I also emphasize: Nothing here is fixed.

每个月都不同。特朗普的立场说变就变。在过去几个月里,特朗普在 Anthropic 和 Dario Amodei 的问题上已反复多次。如果发生另一起重大 AI 事件,或者政治格局发生变化,或者中期选举之后,一切皆有可能。

Every month is different. Trump changes positions on a dime. Trump has gone back and forth several times on Anthropic and Dario Amodei within the last few months. If there is another major AI incident or the politics changes, or after the midterms, anything is possible.

而且其中很多可能是在美中峰会之前故作姿态,以显得强硬并摆出谈判立场,中国对这一切的反应也可能如此。

And a lot of this can be posturing in advance of the US-China summit, to look tough and stake out a negotiating position, as could be China's reactions to all this.

情况看起来不妙。这些表态可能已在某种程度上越过了卢比孔河,将使回头变得更加困难。但过去这并未总能拦住这个人,而且有明确迹象表明特朗普并不理解这一局势。他很可能只听取了贝森特、卢特尼克和 Jensen 中某几位组合的简报。

It does not look good. These statements could have somewhat crossed the Rubicon and will make it harder to double back. But that has not always stopped this man in the past, and there are clear signs that Trump does not understand the situation. He likely has only been briefed by some combination of Bessent, Lutnick and Jensen.

特朗普并不好惹 Trump Does Not Take Kindly

周一,当特朗普发表了一些相当令人担忧的言论时,我曾提醒说,媒体是在妄下结论、误读特朗普的话。没错,特朗普对这一切所传递出的氛围感到不满,但他真正不满的是数据中心。

On Monday, as Trump made some rather concerning statements, I cautioned that the press was jumping to conclusions and misreading what Trump said. Yes, Trump was unhappy about the vibes from all this, but his beef was about the data centers.

唐纳德·特朗普(美国总统):AI 唯一需要的控制或“护栏”,就是一位强大而聪明(高智商!)的总统,而美国恰恰拥有这样一位总统,而且绰绰有余!特朗普政府已经阻止了 AI“人”去做坏的、或可能有坏的“事情”,比如达里奥(Anthropic!),他如今正假装成一个“完美的小天使”——我们还将继续这样做!

Donald Trump (President of the United States): The only control or "guardrails" that AI needs is a STRONG AND SMART (High IQ!) PRESIDENT, and the U.S.A. has that, in spades! The Trump Administration has stopped AI "people" from doing bad, or potentially bad, "things," like Dario (Anthropic!), who is now pretending to be a "perfect little angel" — and we will continue to do so!

我们早已对这些公司拥有巨大的刑事和监管权力!眼下正有一场针对 AI 和数据中心的病态阴谋,而唯一对此感到高兴的就是中国。

We already have tremendous CRIMINAL and REGULATORY power over these companies! There is a SICK conspiracy going on against AI and Data Centers, and the only one that is happy about it is China.

谁赢得 AI,谁就赢得一切!我们正领先于中国以及所有其他国家,并将继续保持领先。阴谋论者、叛国者、卖国贼和泄密者们,当心!感谢各位对此事的关注!

WHOEVER WINS AI, WINS! We are leading China, and all others, and will continue to do so. Conspiracy Theorists, Treasonists, Traitors, and Leakers, BEWARE! Thank you for your attention to this matter!

我坚持我的立场:这番话本可以意味着许多种不同的东西。事情最终的走向远非注定,而贸然跳到最坏结论,只会让那种结局更有可能发生。

I stand by my position that this could have meant any number of things. The way things ultimately went was far from determined, and jumping to the worst-case conclusion only made that ending more likely.

你当然不能把这解读为“美国将零 AI 护栏”,因为特朗普已经设立了超级秘密的 AI 护栏,并出于安全考虑将顶级 AI 模型从市场撤下数周。我们现在也无限期地处在一个白宫任意决定谁可以访问 Claude Mythos 的世界中。

You certainly cannot read this as ‘America will have zero AI guardrails’ when Trump has already instituted super secret AI guardrails and yanked the top AI model from the market for weeks on safety concerns. We are also now indefinitely in a world where the White House arbitrarily decides who gets access to Claude Mythos.

这一切与想要完全没有护栏是不相容的。

None of this is compatible with wanting no guardrails at all.

有些人说,我和 Roon 对媒体过早标题的质疑是各种版本的“疯狂自我安慰”,并指责我们天真或阅读理解能力差。

There were those who said that my and Roon’s challenges of the media’s premature headlines were various versions of ‘insane cope’ and accused us of being naive or having poor reading comprehension.

鉴于所发生的事情,那些人当然赢得了一些贝叶斯点数,而我们失去了这些点数,因为如果事情朝另一个方向发展,我们本可以让他们付出代价而赢得多少点数啊。事情就是这样。我认输。

Certainly those people score some Bayes points given what happened, and we lose them, given how many we would have stood to win at their expense had this gone the other way. That’s how it has to work. I take the L.

我仍然认为这次我“注定会输”,而且当时的解读是正确的。当时,我们没有足够的证据知道它会朝哪个方向发展。

I still think I was ‘supposed to lose’ this one, and that the read was correct. At the time, we had insufficient evidence to know which way it would land.

如果你认为特朗普的第一条评论应当让我们完全更新判断,而他后来的评论没有包含多少信息,那我认为你错了。我仍然认为,在他发表第一条评论时,特朗普本人很可能并不知道他打算在这里做什么。

If you think Trump's first comment should have updated us all the way, and his later comments did not contain much information, I think you are incorrect. I still think it is likely that, at the time of his first comments, Trump himself did not know what he intended to do here.

特朗普彻底称之为“骗局” Trump Goes Full ‘Hoax’

然后有什么事情让他彻底走上了战争之路。我猜是黄仁勋。

Then something got him fully on the warpath. I am guessing it was Jensen Huang.

关于 AI,在商业史上,何时有人见过一个行业的领导者呼吁监管,而如果强力实施,将把他们推向毁灭和破产?

Concerning AI, when, in the History of Business, did anyone see the Leaders of an Industry call for Regulation that, if strongly implemented, will drive them into oblivion and bankruptcy?

AI 接管世界、毁灭人类以及其他所有坏事,是一个骗局,与俄罗斯、俄罗斯、俄罗斯——乌克兰、乌克兰、乌克兰——弹劾骗局#1——弹劾骗局#2——以及美国被迫忍受的所有其他骗局和诡计无异,这些都是通过破坏主义者和异常者的犯规行为和非法行为强加的。

AI taking over the World, destroying Humanity, and all other things bad, is a HOAX, no different from RUSSIA, RUSSIA, RUSSIA — UKRAINE, UKRAINE, UKRAINE — IMPEACHMENT HOAX #1 — IMPEACHMENT HOAX #2 — and all of the other HOAXES and SCAMS that America was forced to endure through the Destructionists’ and Deviants’ foul play and illegal conduct.

中国习近平主席刚刚宣布,中国绝对不会做任何阻碍 AI 或其未来的事情。

President Xi, of China, just announced that China will be doing absolutely nothing to stand in the way of AI, or its future.

谷歌最近表示,他们想在芬兰建立一个大型工厂,完全是因为他们发现在美国获得许可太难了。我对此不高兴,并希望他们改变想法。

Google has recently stated that they want to build a massive Plant in Finland, all because they are finding permitting too difficult in the United States. I am not happy about this, and want them to change their thinking.

AI 与数据中心将成为历史上最伟大的经济发展引擎——其规模超过石油、黄金、钻石,甚至超过互联网。在唐纳德·J·特朗普(DONALD J. TRUMP)总统任期内,它不会被那些运作精妙的破坏性力量所阻止!

AI, and Data Centers, will be the Greatest Economic Development Engine in History — Bigger than Oil, Gold, Diamonds, or even the Internet. It will not be stopped by brilliantly run Destructive Forces during the Term of President DONALD J. TRUMP!

总统先生,这与数据中心无关 This Is Not About Data Centers, Mr. President

AI/数据中心爆发式增长的唯一原因,是美国大幅领先于其他所有国家。不要杀死下金蛋的鹅!

The only reason the AI/Data Center outburst is happening is because the United States is leading, by a lot, every other country. Don't kill the Golden Goose!

听起来特朗普确实认为这些警告是针对数据中心的阴谋?尽管 Dario Amodei、Sam Altman 和 Elon Musk 正是最积极推动在美国建设数据中心的五个人中的三位,并且通过他们的公司为其中很大一部分积极提供资金。得有人告诉总统。

It sure sounds like Trump thinks these warnings are a plot against data centers? Despite the fact that Dario Amodei and Sam Altman and Elon Musk are three of the top five people most heavily pushing to build American data centers, and actively funding a large fraction of them via their companies. Someone tell the President.

可以理解这种压缩是怎么形成的。不,这毫无道理,但生活就是这样。

One can see how that compression got made. No, it makes no sense, but such is life.

那些说 AI 将毁灭世界、数据中心对社区有害的人,正是不久前还说世界将被“气候变化”毁灭的那批人。

The people that say AI is going to destroy the World, and that Data Centers are bad for your neighborhood, are the same people that said, just a short time ago, that the World would be extinguished by “Climate Change.”

那个骗局从未得逞,现在他们又转向下一个了。

That HOAX never worked out for them, and now they’re on to the next one.

这些人是革命者,但却是为糟糕而邪恶的事业而战的革命者。很快你就会发现,他们是在为那些并不把美国的最佳利益放在心上的人效力!

These people are Revolutionaries, but Revolutionaries for a Bad and Evil Cause. Soon you'll find out they're working for people that do not have the best interests of the United States in mind!

我不打算去争辩究竟是哪些失误可能或不可能导致了事情最终如此发展。过去已成过去。这才是我们的当下。

I am not going to try to litigate which missteps may or may not have contributed to this being the way it played out. The past is the past. This is our present.

我是骗局终结者,我是骗局终结者,我是海象 I Am The Hoax Buster, I Am The Hoax Buster, I Am The Walrus

然后事情就发展到了另一个层面。

And then things went, well, to another level.

我是骗局终结者,我现在正在揭穿另一个骗局——即 AI 将会接管、吞噬并毁灭世界,机器人将会进军我们的城市,并消灭我们所有人!

I am the Hoax Buster, and I’m right now breaking another Hoax — That AI is going to take over, consume, and destroy the World, and that Robots will be marching into our Cities, and getting rid of us all!

这甚至比“俄罗斯、俄罗斯、俄罗斯”骗局或全球变暖骗局更加疯狂。

This is even wilder than the RUSSIA, RUSSIA, RUSSIA HOAX, or the Global Warming Scam.

我知道这是悲剧性的、可怕的,以及许多其他糟糕的事情。但是。

I know this is tragic, horrible and many other things. But.

如果你能把这些放在一边,它也非常好笑。这首歌还需要一些打磨,不幸的是 Grok 没法让他唱出来,但我告诉你,这里面有点东西。他是个独一无二的天才。我写不出那个。你也写不出那个。

If you can set those things aside it is also extremely funny. The song needs some work and unfortunately Grok can’t make him sing, but I tell you, there’s something there. He’s a singular talent. I couldn’t write that. You couldn’t write that.

多米尼克·罗马诺:唐尼·骗局终结者已经发话了!🤣

Dominick Romano: Donnie Hoax Buster has spoken! 🤣

根据阿斯特拉的统计,这至少将是第 20 个此类骗局,与夏洛茨维尔、俄罗斯、俄罗斯悬赏美国军人、机密文件案、纽约民事欺诈案、E·让·卡罗尔的指控、他与爱泼斯坦有联系、对布雷特·卡瓦诺的指控、负担能力危机、官方失业率、‘傻瓜和失败者’故事、‘血洗’争议、布巴·华莱士绞索事件、对他应对新冠的批评、气候变化、因乌克兰问题首次弹劾、第二次弹劾、将 1 月 6 日视为叛乱、拜登赢得 2020 年大选,以及现在 AI 具有生存风险等并列。

By Astra’s count this will be at least the 20th such Hoax, joining Charlottesville, Russia, Russian bounties on American troops, the classified documents case, the New York civil fraud case, the accusations by E. Jean Carroll, that he has connections to Epstein, the accusations against Brett Kavanaugh, the affordability crisis, the official unemployment rate, the ‘suckers and losers’ story, the ‘bloodbath’ controversy, the Bubba Wallace noose incident, criticism of his response to Covid, climate change, first impeachment over Ukraine, second impeachment, January 6 as an insurrection, Biden winning the 2020 election and now that AI has existential risks.

这就是现实。这就是地球。这是 2026 年。我们看到美国总统这样说话,我们都想‘是的,我们知道,就是这样。’

This is reality. This is Earth. This is 2026. We saw that the President of the United States talks this way and we all thought ‘yeah, we know, that’s just how it is.’

英伟达 CEO 黄仁勋是个彻头彻尾的骗子 Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang Is a Lying Liar

人们声称没有注意到他是一个不断撒谎的骗子,这简直是荒谬至极。

It is patently absurd that people claim not to notice that he is a constantly lying liar.

执行摘要:新闻:黄仁勋称前 Anthropic 研究员 Jacob Coxon 的推文“古怪、极不真实、傲慢且对行业的安全工作一无所知”。

Exec Sum: NEWS: Jensen Huang says ex-Anthropic researcher Jacob Coxon's tweets are "outlandish, deeply untrue, arrogant and ignorant of the industry's safety work."

后来,在 All-In 峰会上,Jensen 会缓和这一说法。

Later, at the All-In Summit, Jensen would moderate that.

Axios:[Jensen]表示,举报人的警告应被认真对待,并赞扬 Anthropic 举报人 Jacob Coxon 有“极大的勇气”对公司 AI 开发过快提出担忧。

Axios: [Jensen] said warnings from whistleblowers should be taken seriously, praising Anthropic whistleblower Jacob Coxon for having "great courage" to raise his concerns about the company's AI development going too quickly.

然后他又回过头来假装这一切都能靠普通的产品责任和市场力量解决。如果你的 AI 把所有人都杀了,那我们就起诉你,再也没人买你的产品,到时候你可就惨了。

Then he goes back to pretending this is all solved by ordinary product liability and market forces. If your AI kills everyone then we will sue you, and no one will buy your product anymore, and boy will you be sorry.

黄仁勋:如果你打造一款产品或服务,却对其功能、能力或安全性没有信心,那就别发布它……市场力量已经在那儿了。我们不需要任何新法律。我们不需要新监管。

Jensen Huang: If you build a product or a service and you're not confident in its functionality, capability, or safety, then don't release it … The market forces are already there. We don't need any new laws. We don't need new regulations.

想必你注意到了:不,我们不会起诉你,因为我们都已经死了。

Presumably you noticed that no, we won't sue you, on account of being dead and all.

黄仁勋是一个极度愤世嫉俗的商业和政治行为者,他唯一的目标就是把英伟达芯片卖给任何他能卖的人,尤其是中国。这一点再清楚不过了。

Jensen is a maximally cynical commercial and political actor whose one and only goal is to sell Nvidia chips to whoever he can, especially China. This could not be clearer.

Matthew Yglesias:如果“但中国”是你对控制前沿发展节奏的顾虑,那你不能*同时*又支持向中国出口各种芯片,那只是“让英伟达股价上涨”,而不是对华或对人工智能的真正政策。

Matthew Yglesias: If "but China" is your qualm about pacing the frontier you can't *also* be for exporting all kinds of chips to China, that's just "make NVIDIA stock go up" not a real policy toward China or artificial intelligence.

EigenGender(Anthropic):与其愤世嫉俗地认为 Dario 一直在推行一项长达十年的计划(早在 Anthropic 创立之前就已开始)以进行监管俘获,不如愤世嫉俗地想想:这个名副其实的全球最大公司的掌门人告诉你一切都没问题,只是为了多卖些 GPU。

EigenGender (Anthropic): instead of being cynical that Dario has been engaging in a decade-long plan (starting from long before Anthropic was created) to do regulatory capture, be cynical that the leader of the literal largest company in the world is telling you everything is fine to sell more GPUs.

Jensen 关于 AI 生存性风险、或任何 AI 负面影响的言论,早已不再假装与现实有任何关联——除了对 Nvidia 有利的那部分。

Jensen's statements about AI existential risk, or any AI downsides, long ago stopped pretending to have any correlation with reality, other than what is good for Nvidia.

litquidity:我还是选择相信 Jensen,一位经验丰富、久经考验的领导者,而不是某个不知从哪儿冒出来、发些 AI 末日论垃圾、还到处上媒体巡演的随便什么人。

litquidity: I'm gonna go ahead and trust Jensen, an established leader with immense experience, vs. some random dude who came out of nowhere to post AI Doomer slop and go on a press tour.

Leo Gao(OpenAI):我敢打赌,jacob 对“这个行业的安全工作”的了解比 jensen 多。

Leo Gao (OpenAI): i bet jacob knows more about "the industry's safety work" than jensen

Jensen 不在乎世界是否被毁灭,只要他能拥有一家伟大的公司。他本来就已经有了,但这样一来,它能稍微更伟大一点。又一次。

Jensen does not care if the world is destroyed, so long as he gets to have a great company. Which he already had, but this way it is slightly more great. Again.

在 All-In 科技峰会上(当然),黄仁勋登台陈述自己的观点,并接了一通来自特朗普的约五分钟电话。

At the All-In Tech Summit (of course), Jensen Huang went onstage to make his case, and took an about five minute phone call from Trump.

唐纳德·特朗普(电话中):他们正中了那些不希望看到这件事发生的人的下怀。政界人士,还有中国。我们不会让这种事发生。这是个骗局。

Donald Trump (on the phone): They're playing right into the hands of a lot of people that don't want to see it happen. Political people, and also China. We're not going to let that happen. It's a hoax.

不同转录版本之间对于此处的“他们”指谁存在争议。主持人提供的一份转录将这一指代归于[末日论者],我认为这大体上就是此处的本意。

There is dispute between transcripts over who 'they' refers to here. The hosts offer a transcript that attributes this to [doomers] and I believe that was the broad intent here.

特朗普悄然做出关键区分 Trump Quietly Draws Key Distinction

我确实从一些词语细节中得到安慰。面对像特朗普这样的混乱制造者,你仔细的解读总会被事件超越,事情不断变化。我意识到这听起来像在吹毛求疵。好吧。

I do take solace in some word details. With a chaos agent like Trump, your careful interpretations can always get overtaken by events, things change constantly. I realize this is going to sound like splitting hairs. Fine.

但请注意,他说‘末日论者’正‘落入’某些人的‘圈套’。

But notice that he’s saying the ‘doomers’ are ‘playing right into the hands’ of people.

这隐含承认,在特朗普看来,警告我们的‘末日论者’是真诚的。你不会‘落入’你的同谋或盟友的‘圈套’。这是你用来描述政治中所谓的‘有用白痴’的语言,即一个相信自己所讲的话,却以有利于他人的方式行事的人。

That is an implicit admission that, in Trump’s mind, the ‘doomers’ warning us are sincere. You do not ‘play into the hands of’ your co-conspirators or allies. This is the language you use to describe what in politics is called a Useful Idiot, someone who believes what they are saying in a way that acts to someone else’s advantage.

特朗普称这是‘骗局’,是因为他相信——尝试造一个短语——所谓的基于暗示的认识论。历史上,这对他很有效。你可能不喜欢,但这正是峰值证据决策理论的样子。

Trump is calling this a ‘hoax’ because he believes in, to attempt to coin a phrase, what one might call implication-based epistemology. Historically it has worked well for him. You may not like it, but this is what Peak Evidential Decision Theory looks like.

呼吁放缓前沿 AI 发展对 AI 股价不利 Calling For Pacing the Frontier Is Bad For AI Stock Prices

Zac Hill 是最新一位提醒我们的人:如果 AI 公司想向美国推销他们的新技术,他们所做的几乎会与现在完全相反。然而,产品本身仍然会自我推销。

Zac Hill is the latest to remind us that if AI companies wanted to sell America on their new technology, they would do pretty much the opposite of what they are doing. Yet the product still sells itself.

这一切都显而易见,这也是为什么 Jensen 和 Trump 如此执着于称其为“骗局”。但许多人仍然持相反观点,所以让我们说得更明确些:

This is all utterly obvious, and is why Jensen and Trump are so bent on calling this a ‘hoax.’ But many people still think the opposite, so let us be even more explicit:

Alex Tabarrok(周一):全球 AI 股票今日下跌。这完全符合我的观点,即呼吁 AI 安全并非试图进行“监管俘获”,也完全不符合那种所谓愤世嫉俗且老练的观点,即 AI 恐惧都是为提高收入而下的四维象棋。

Alex Tabarrok (on Monday): Global AI stocks fell today. Entirely consistent with my view that calls for AI safety are not an attempt at “regulatory capture” and entirely inconsistent with the supposedly cynic-sophisticated view that AI fears are all 4D chess moves for higher revenue.

Michael Burry 已从称 AI 为泡沫转向称其为卡特尔。根据 Tabarrok 解释并由 Jensen 和 Trump 的反应所证明的原因,这毫无道理。就他而言,我不认为他在撒谎。我认为 Burry 只是陷得太深了。

Michael Burry has moved on from calling AI a bubble to calling it a cartel. For the reasons explained by Tabarrok, and demonstrated by the reactions of Jensen and Trump, this makes no sense. In his case I do not think he is lying. I think Burry is just in way too deep.

Matt Levine 不知何故不同意。他认为 Dario Amodei 的呼吁完全真诚,并且通过扩大总可寻址市场和降低训练成本,也是极好的营销。Matt Levine 总是非常风趣,擅长处理由齿轮构成的金融基础设施,并且善于为所有极其荒谬的主张——无论是反垄断违规、极好的营销还是典型的证券欺诈——构建钢铁侠论证。是的,你可以想象这样的抱怨,事实上我见过。

Matt Levine somehow disagrees. He thinks that Dario Amodei’s call was entirely sincere and also great marketing by expanding the total addressable market and reducing training costs. Matt Levine is always very funny, and excellent with financial infrastructure made of gears, and is great for making a steelman of all utterly ridiculous claims that something is an antitrust violation, great marketing or classically securities fraud. Yes, you can imagine such complaints, indeed I have seen them.

Matt Levine 从来不太感兴趣的是,他构建的荒谬的钢铁侠论点是否有任何价值,或者是否有人能真诚地说出它。那不是他的部门。他在这里是为了沉思。我尊重这一点。

What Matt Levine has never been that interested in is whether the ludicrous steelman he constructs has any merit, or whether anyone could actually say it in good faith. That’s not his department. He is here to muse. I respect that.

Matt Levine(彭博社):我在这里有一个持续的笑话,关于美国法律体系中可能阻止人工超级智能杀死我们所有人的奇怪漏洞。比如,如果版权规则或《洋葱期货法》或“一切都是证券欺诈”是阻止 AI 变得无所不能的原因呢?这个笑话随着时间的推移变得不那么好笑了,部分原因是 AI 已经直接冲过了其中一些法律漏洞。(还记得曾认为版权法可能会限制 AI 公司吗?)

Matt Levine (Bloomberg): I have a running joke around here about weird wrinkles of the US legal system that might stop artificial superintelligence from killing us all. Like, what if copyright rules or the Onion Futures Act or “everything is securities fraud” is what prevents AI from becoming all-powerful? That joke has become less funny over time, in part because AI has run right over some of those legal wrinkles. (Remember thinking that copyright law might limit AI companies?)

但我想现在反过来也是一种可能性。如果那些最有能力阻止失控超级智能的善意人类愿意合作阻止它,但他们因为反垄断法而无法做到呢?

But I suppose the reverse is now a possibility. What if the well-meaning humans in the best position to stop rogue superintelligence are willing to work together to stop it, but they can’t because of antitrust law?

永远不要改变,Matt Levine,小丑可以对国王说真话:

Never change, Matt Levine, the jester can speak truth to the king:

Matt Levine(彭博社):

Matt Levine (Bloomberg):

我在这里已经写过好几次,关于人工智能时代科技行业面临的一个问题,即(1)顶尖科技员工的现行薪酬是“足够让他们立刻退休的钱”,以及(2)如果他们真的退休了怎么办?如果你付给员工的薪酬足以与其他公司竞争,你就会付给他们足够多的钱,让他们不必再工作。那你还怎么激励任何人?我们讨论过两种可能的解决方案,分别是:

I have written a handful of times around here about a problem facing the technology industry in the age of artificial intelligence, which is that (1) the going rate for top tech employees is "enough money that they can retire immediately" and (2) what if they do? If you pay employees enough to be competitive with other companies, you will be paying them enough that they don't have to work anymore. How can you motivate anyone? We have discussed two possible solutions, which are:

1. “3000 万美元能在旧金山都会区买一套两居室”,以及

1. "$30 million will buy you a two-bedroom in the San Francisco metro area," and

2. 不知为何,AI 研究人员中普遍存在的一种信念——他们的工作会杀死地球上的所有人——似乎反而激励他们继续做下去,而不是趁还能享受的时候辞职去享受财富。

2. For some reason the widespread belief, among AI researchers, that their work will kill everyone on earth seems to motivate them to keep doing it rather than quit and enjoy their money while they can.

我意识到第二种解决方案有悖直觉,老实说第一种也是(离开旧金山!),但无所谓了。

I realize that the second solution is counterintuitive, and honestly the first is too (leave San Francisco!), but whatever.

互联网上的人有时会说谎 People On The Internet Sometimes Lie

众所周知,人身攻击几乎是辩论的最低层次,但实际上还有一个更低的层次:人身攻击同时也是完全违背事实的。

Ad hominem is famously almost the lowest level of discourse, but actually there is an additional lower level: ad hominem attacks that are also exactly the opposite of true.

Erick Erickson(说谎):核能末日论者变成了气候末日论者,现在他们又成了 AI 末日论者。唯一的共同点是他们希望美国衰落。

Erick Erickson (lying): The nuclear power doomers became the climate doomers and now they’re the AI doomers. The only commonality is they want the United States to recede.

事实恰恰相反。那些担心 AI 的人一直绝大多数支持核能,而且我们知道气候变化是真实的,但这些人几乎从来不是‘气候末日论者’,并且多年来一直主张将注意力放在别处。这是彻头彻尾的谎言。要么 Erick 在说谎,要么他被骗了却根本不屑于核实。

The opposite is true. Those worried about AI have always overwhelmingly favored nuclear power and we know climate change is real but such folks are almost never ‘climate doomers’ and have argued for years to focus elsewhere. This is straight lying. Either Erick is lying, or he has been lied to and did not care to check, at all.

怀疑论的起源 Origins of Cynicism

很多人说人工智能可能杀死所有人。其中许多人是有资格知情的。

A lot of people say that AI might kill everyone. A lot of them are in a position to know.

有些人认为“他们相信这一点”作为解释说不通。为什么?

There are those for whom ‘they believe it’ does not compute as an explanation. Why?

Aella:时间线上那么多人无法接受这样一种理论:对领导者许多行为的最简单解释就是他们真心相信人工智能是生存威胁。

Aella: So many people on the timeline can’t entertain the theory that the simplest explanation for a lot of the behavior of the leaders is that they earnestly believe AI is an existential threat.

也许如果你自己掌权时不会说真诚的话,就很难想象这一点?

Maybe it’s hard to imagine if you personally would not say earnest things when in power?

Rob Bensinger:我不认为这种心态是“AI 风险是可能的,但他们是骗子,所以在这件事上他们一定在撒谎”。人们直觉地认为,如果你把一个骗子放在着火的建筑里,他们会喊“着火了!”而不是“水!”。

Rob Bensinger: I don’t think the mindset is “AI risk is plausible, but they’re liars, so they must be lying about this”. People intuit that if you put a liar in a burning building, they’ll scream “FIRE!” rather than “WATER!”.

相反,我认为这种心态是“AI 风险显然很荒谬,因此……”

Rather, I think the mindset is "AI risk is obviously silly, ergo..."

我认为这是相信所有人都在此事上说谎的三个主要真实理由中的两个,我将其总结为:

I think those are two of the three main true reasons for believing that everyone is lying about this, which I would summarize as:

1. 或者:所有掌权者都说谎,或者所有人都在说谎,或者所有人总是为自己的利益和私利说话。

1. Alternatively: Everyone with power lies, or everyone lies, or everyone always talks their own book and their own self-interest.

2. 那听起来很奇怪,因此它不是真的。

2. That sounds weird, therefore it is not real.

3. 那会非常糟糕,因此它不是真的。

3. That would be very bad, therefore it is not true.

那么,在这三种情况下都是如此:因此,他们在撒谎,证明完毕。

Then, in all three cases: Therefore, they are lying, QED.

David Shor 向我们推荐了一篇 2018 年的论文,题为《犬儒天才的错觉:探索并驳斥关于犬儒主义与能力的世俗信念》,以此作为这种思维方式的例证。那些“银河级大脑”们纷纷出动了。

David Shor links us to a paper from 2018 called The Cynical Genius Illusion: Exploring and Debunking Lay Beliefs About Cynicism and Competence, as illustrative of this style of thinking. The galaxy brains are out in force.

人们说,这既是一种抬高估值的犬儒式伎俩,也是一种在估值下跌时预设借口的犬儒式伎俩。

This is both, people say, a cynical ploy to pump up valuations, and a cynical ploy to set up excuses if valuations go down.

Jersey Lee(说错了):我认为这是一种抬高估值的信息,同时也反映了一种算计:即使公众强烈反对,也不会有重大的监管。

Jersey Lee (being wrong): I think it is a message to pump up valuations, while at the same time reflects a calculus that there won't be significant regulations even if the public is strongly opposed.

Aella:看到一个视频,他们在说:其实 AI 高管们并不是为了抬高股价而宣称末日,他们实际上是为了在股价下跌时有个借口而宣称末日。真是太多方便的故事了!

Aella: saw a vid where they're saying: actually instead of the AI execs claiming doom to pump the stock, they're actually claiming doom so it'll be an excuse when the stock drops. So many convenient stories!

无效利己主义 Ineffective Egoism

绝对不必因为“有效利他主义者”被点名而恐慌。

Definitely do not panic about 'Effective Altruists' being called out by name.

这场寻找替罪羊的运动早在很久以前就开始了,由 Marc Andreessen 带头推动。

This scapegoat campaign started long ago, spearheaded by Marc Andreessen.

Brunella(30 万+ 播放):兄弟,他们要对有效利他主义者搞麦卡锡主义了

Brunella (300k+ views): bro they're gonna do McCarthyism to effective altruists

我的意思是,别误会,a16z 一直在努力,而且他们在某些方面确实让这个词在政治领域成了贬义词。但这种盲目的愤怒,如果说有什么影响的话,反倒应该受到欢迎。

I mean, don't get me wrong, a16z has been trying, and they have in some ways made it a dirty word in politics in particular. But this kind of blind rage should, if anything, be welcomed.

对于那些认为一旦 AI 失控我们就会集体携手应对的人,我想说:美国战争部已经失控了,却似乎没人有意采取任何行动,也许是因为它显然如此无效。

For those who think that if an AI went rogue we would all collectively work together to deal with it, well, the US Department of War has gone rogue and no one seems inclined to do anything about it, perhaps because it is so obviously ineffective.

战争部 CTO:要美国主义,不要有效利他主义。

Department of War CTO: Americanism, not effective altruism.

美国将继续保持 AI 主导地位!🇺🇸

The United States will continue to be AI DOMINANT! 🇺🇸

Alex Tabarrok:想象一下战争部发推说“功利主义者陷入混乱!康德主义者仓皇逃窜!”从来没有哪种哲学重要到值得被政府攻击。直到 EA(有效利他主义)。惊人的成功。

Alex Tabarrok: Imagine the Department of War tweeting "Utilitarians in shambles! Kantians on the run!" No philosophy has ever mattered enough to be attacked by the government. Until EA. Amazing success.

起初他们忽视你,然后他们嘲笑你,然后他们攻击你,然后你就赢了。

First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win.

这还会引发斯特赖桑德效应(Streisand Effect)。基本上没人知道有效利他主义是什么,也不知道围绕 AI 存在性风险的大多数观点。如果你开始猛烈抨击 EA,尤其是在一个高度两极化的环境中,你觉得会发生什么?

This also invokes the Streisand Effect. Essentially no one knows what Effective Altruism is, or most of the ideas around AI existential risk. If you start railing against EA, especially in a highly polarized environment, what do you think happens?

试图发起一场新的麦卡锡主义不仅不会奏效,还会让所有人都说‘嘿,看看他们想对这东西搞麦卡锡主义。’

Attempting to launch a new McCarthyism not only will not work, it will cause everyone to go 'hey check out this thing they're trying to do a McCarthyism on.'

然后他们发现这是关于通过慈善尽力做最大的善事。

And then they find out it's about trying to do the most good via charity.

马修·伊格莱西亚斯:最近许多关于构建外星超级智能种族之危险的随意言论,都来自与有效利他主义这一晦涩意识形态有关联的人。

Matthew Yglesias: A lot of loose talk lately about the dangers of building a race of alien super-intelligences comes from people affiliated with the obscure ideology of Effective Altruism.

要警惕这些人物,他们对最大化英伟达收益等关键目标构成威胁。

Be on the lookout for these characters who pose a threat to critical goals like maximizing NVIDIA earnings.

麦卡锡主义派系攻击 METR The McCarthyist Faction Attacks METR

这是一个合乎逻辑的首个目标。也许我该更担心一些,但主要是我觉得这适得其反,更重要的是,这很滑稽。

This is a logical first target. Maybe I should be more concerned, but mostly I find it counterproductive and, more importantly, hilarious.

这是《纽约邮报》真实的头版,把这件事与往届的“佳作”如《无头尸体在无上装酒吧》并列供奉:

This is the actual, real-life front page of the New York Post, enshrining this story alongside past winners like 'Headless Body in Topless Bar':

《纽约邮报》:Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei 亲手挑选的 AI 监督者与觉醒的有效利他主义运动有深厚联系:“一个彻头彻尾的笑话”

New York Post: Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei's handpicked AI watchdog has deep ties to woke Effective Altruism movement: 'a complete joke'

vik:令人担忧

vik: concerning

Thomas Barrabi(《纽约邮报》):METR 那位自诩的 John Connors 声称完全独立,但该组织的根源可直接追溯到有效利他主义的关键人物,其在硅谷的追随者中曾包括声名狼藉的加密货币老板 Sam Bankman-Fried,而他是 Anthropic 早期最大的投资者之一。

Thomas Barrabi (New York Post): The would-be John Connors at METR purport to be fully independent, but the group traces its roots directly back to key figures in Effective Altruism, whose Silicon Valley-based devotees once included disgraced crypto boss Sam Bankman-Fried, one of Anthropic’s biggest early investors.

如果有一个新版 Pangram,能用 AI 检测“恶意攻击文章腔调”,你根本不需要它,因为这太经典了。你看,[A] 声称独立于 [B],但 [A] 的根源可追溯到 [C],而 [C] 曾与 [D] 有联系,[D] 是个坏透了的家伙,他曾与 [B] 有关联,所以将死 [外群体],我们已经发现了你们的阴谋。

If there was a new version of Pangram that used AI to detect Hack Job Hit Piece Voice, you would not need it, because this is so classic. You see, [A] claims to be independent of [B], but [A] traces its roots back to [C], which once associated with [D], and [D] was a bad, bad person, who once was associated with [B], so checkmate [outgroup], we have discovered your conspiracy.

全文都延续这种腔调。你看,METR 竟然有(倒吸一口气)有效利他主义者,而且一些投资 Anthropic 的人也资助了 METR,比如 Jaan Tallinn,这必定是某种大阴谋。诸如此类。零新事实,甚至没有任何关注此事的人不知道的内容。

It continues in this vein throughout. You see, there are (gasp) Effective Altruists at METR, and some of the same people who invested in Anthropic also helped fund METR, like Jaan Tallinn, it must be some grand conspiracy. And so on. There are zero new facts, or even anything that is not common knowledge among those paying attention.

“彻头彻尾的笑话”这句话来自 Perry Metzger,他四处发帖,在包括我自己的多条 Twitter 帖子下回复疯狂的咆哮,并且是行业反监管组织“未来联盟”的主席。这让人可以猜测 Barrabi 这篇攻击文章的来源。

The ‘complete joke’ line was obtained from Perry Metzger, who goes around posting unhinged rants in reply to various Twitter posts including my own, and is chairman of the industry anti-regulation group Alliance for the Future. That offers a guess as to the origins of Barrabi’s hit piece.

这个也是如此,它要么表明白宫内部存在深度混淆(他们以制造此类混淆而闻名),要么表明消息来源在编造事实。

So does this, which could be either a deep confusion at the White House, where they have been known to make such conflations, or the source making things up.

Thomas Barrabi(《纽约邮报》):“METR 本质上就是另一个形式的 Anthropic,”一位熟悉白宫想法的消息人士周二对《邮报》表示。

Thomas Barrabi (New York Post): "METR is essentially Anthropic in another form," a source familiar with the White House's thinking told The Post on Tuesday.

“woke”这个标签纯粹是他们塞进标题和第一句话里的东西,一如既往,既没有任何事实依据,也没有提供任何证据。METR 在任何意义上都绝不是“woke”。

The 'woke' label is purely something they threw into the headline and first sentence, with neither any actual truth to it nor any evidence provided, as per usual. METR is not, in any sense whatsoever, 'woke.'

标题里的“全球主义者”标签完全是前言不搭后语。老套路了。

The 'globalist' label in the headline is a complete non-sequitur. Usual playbook.

另一个隐含的论点是:看看这些大幅照片,这么多 METR 的知名员工,他们不像 Dario Amodei,上镜好看、形象出众。

The other implicit argument is: look at these large photos of so many prominent METR employees who, unlike Dario Amodei, photograph well and look good.

这并不是说潜在的利益冲突就不存在问题。是的,我们当然也希望有能带来额外视角的审计方,在 Anthropic 以及其他地方与 METR 并肩工作。如果你想要那种“公平竞争”式的外部视角攻击文章,请看 SE Gyges。

That is not to say that there are no issues with potential conflicts of interest. Yes, of course we also will want auditors that bring additional perspectives, to work alongside METR, both at Anthropic and elsewhere. If you want the 'fair play' outside-view hit piece, see SE Gyges.

这里真正存在的问题是众所周知的、已被承认的,而且是不可避免的。你需要前实验室员工以及那些背景与实验室有关联的人,因为除此之外没有人具备完成这项工作的技术专长。而且你需要让审计人员获得足够高的报酬以吸引优秀人才,同时又不为他们的服务收费,这意味着你需要向关心此类问题的慈善家募资。大多数行业都存在某种形式的完全相同的问题。

The issues that are real here are well known, acknowledged, and were not avoidable. You need former lab employees and those whose backgrounds have links to the labs, because no one else has the technical expertise to do the job. And you need auditors to get paid enough to attract strong talent and not charge for their services, which means you need to hit up the philanthropists who care about such issues. Most industries have some form of exactly this problem.

如果你能建立自己的、从外部视角看高度可信且技术能力强的监督组织来在这个领域竞争,那将真的很棒,你会彻底击败那些自由派。天哪,我希望没有人这么做,我们绝对不需要更多这样的努力。那将真是遗憾。

It would be really great, you would totally own the libs, if you were to spin up your own outside view highly credible and technically competent monitoring organizations to compete in this space. My lord, I hope no one does that, we definitely don't need a lot more such efforts. Would be a real shame.

如果你说,为了对 Anthropic 形成真正的制约,你需要让审计和评估人员具有普遍性、强制性并受法律保护,并且以其他方式赋予其更多权力以成为‘真正的制约’,那对 Anthropic 和 METR 来说会更糟。

It would be even worse for Anthropic and METR if you were to say that in order to generate a real check on Anthropic you need the audits and evaluators to be universal, mandatory and protected by law, and otherwise given more teeth to be a 'real check.'

作为额外的有趣色彩,这是该记者之前的黑客式打击工作,有人说那甚至更有趣,但不幸的是被拒绝登上头版:

For additional fun color, this was the reporter's previous hack hit job effort, which some say was even funnier but was tragically denied the front page:

Dean W. Ball(OpenAI):同一个记者 [Thomas Barrabi],顺便说一句,就是那个对 Caleb Watney 做了那篇恶毒攻击文章的人

Dean W. Ball (OpenAI): same reporter [Thomas Barrabi] who did that nasty hit piece on caleb watney btw

Alexander Berger:嘿,他们将会卖出很多份。

Alexander Berger: hey they're going to be selling a lot of copies

Dean W. Ball(OpenAI):《纽约邮报》分析团队对突然激增的配送量感到困惑,这些配送都涌向电报大道上的这个地址。

Dean W. Ball (OpenAI): New York Post analytics staff befuddled by sudden uptick in delivery volume to this one address on Telegraph Ave

Dean W. Ball(OpenAI):对于第三方评估者,那些新近形成观点的人不应受到赞助。非专家快速形成观点是美国传统的一部分。在非常重要的意义上,宪法本身是由 20 多岁的年轻人凭感觉编码的,他们只有一个计划的概念。

Dean W. Ball (OpenAI): nobody should patronize those who newly have opinions about third party evaluators. non-experts forming opinions fast is part of the American tradition. the Constitution itself was, in a very important sense, vibe coded by 20-somethings with concepts of a plan.

但新手被宰也是美国传统的一部分。“买者自负”是成年人签署的合同条款,而不是某种天赋权利,让你不被当作小孩对待。无论怎样,你都会被当作小孩对待。

but newbies being fleeced is also part of the American tradition. “caveat emptor” is a provision of a contract signed by an adult, not some god-given right to be treated as something other than a little child. you will be treated as a child no matter what.

你是买家。提防是你的职责。

You are the buyer. It is your job to beware.

确实有种种迹象表明,这是一场针对 METR 的协同抹黑行动,目的是让其在右翼回音室中显得糟糕。接下来几周对 METR 的人来说很可能在很多方面都很难熬,尤其是当一些相当恶毒的人四处挖掘哪怕一丁点真正的黑料时。我不认为这会奏效;事实上,我预计它会因斯特赖桑德效应而适得其反。

There are indeed all the signs of a coordinated smear campaign against METR to make them sound bad to right-wing echo chambers. The next few weeks are likely to suck in many ways for the METR folks, especially as some rather vicious people dig around for the tiniest bit of actual dirt. I do not expect this to work; indeed, I expect it to backfire via the Streisand Effect.

尽可能一笑置之。保持坚强。把它挂进卢浮宫。

Laugh it off as best you can. Stay strong. Hang it in the Louvre.

其他关键共和党人的反应 Other Key Republicans React

也有许多共和党人,其主流派系由罗恩·德桑蒂斯领导,但越来越多其他人也逐渐理解其中的利害关系,或只是理解政治。

There are also many Republicans, with the mainstream arm of that led by Ron DeSantis but also increasingly many others, who increasingly understand the stakes or simply understand the politics.

“惯常嫌疑人”可能让特朗普目前谈论一场骗局,但这仍是一个两党合作的时刻,许多人不会盲目跟从。即使现在,这个问题也常常保持显著的两党合作性质,不仅当你在舞台上看到史蒂夫·班农与伯尼·桑德斯同台时如此。

The Usual Suspects may have Trump currently talking about a hoax, but this remains a bipartisan moment, and many are not going to fall in line. Even now the issue often remains remarkably bipartisan, and not only when you see Steve Bannon on stage with Bernie Sanders.

Axios 的文章主要关于对 HuggingFace 攻击的两党调查,其中参议员霍利带头,但也包括更近期的担忧。

Axios’s post is largely about the bipartisan investigation of the HuggingFace attacks where Senator Hawley is taking point, but it also includes the more recent concerns.

安德鲁·索伦德:希望监管 AI 的立法者正在做一件不寻常的事,因为国会正冲向一个漫长的休会期,而看不到任何切实的解决方案:他们正在跨党派合作。

Andrew Solender: Lawmakers who want to regulate AI are doing something unusual as Congress barrels towards a lengthy recess with no tangible solution in sight: They're working across the aisle.

……最新的例子:参议员乔什·霍利(密苏里州共和党)和理查德·布卢门撒尔(康涅狄格州民主党)正在向国会领导层施压,要求对他们的法案进行投票,以建立一个评估和监控 AI 系统的联邦项目。

… The latest example: Sens. Josh Hawley (R-Mo.) and Richard Blumenthal (D-Conn.) are pressing congressional leadership for a vote on their bill to establish a federal program to assess and monitor AI systems.

……事态进展:自 Anthropic 和 OpenAI 的几名现任和前任员工公开表达对其产品构成的生存风险的担忧后的一周内,出现了几项新的两党监管 AI 的努力。

… State of play: Several new bipartisan efforts to regulate AI have cropped up in the week since several current and former employees at Anthropic and OpenAI went public with concerns about the existential risks posed by their own products.

* 据 Axios 周一报道,众议员 Russell Fry(南卡罗来纳州共和党)和 Suhas Subramanyam(弗吉尼亚州民主党)正在成立一个专注于 AI 小企业的党团,名为“创新者党团”。

* Reps. Russell Fry (R-S.C.) and Suhas Subramanyam (D-Va.) are founding a caucus focused on AI small businesses, called the Innovators Caucus, as Axios reported Monday.

* 该组织宣称的目标之一是开始制定监管 AI 的联邦框架,并让小企业参与 AI 政策制定。

* Among the group’s stated goals is starting work on a federal framework to regulate AI, as well as bringing small businesses to the AI policymaking table.

众议院议长 Mike Johnson 继续表现得理智,而报道却继续奇怪。首先 Politico 试图让它听起来像是 Johnson 想完全把责任推给公司,现在彭博社又说,他因非常温和的声明而‘冒着激怒特朗普的风险’:

House Speaker Mike Johnson continues to act sanely and this continues to be reported strangely. First Politico tried to make it sound like Johnson wanted to fully pass the buck to the companies, and now Bloomberg says he ‘risks Trump’s wrath’ over his very milquetoast statements:

Michael Shepard、Erik Wasson 和 Hadriana Lowenkron(彭博社):共和党众议院议长 Mike Johnson 冒着激怒特朗普的风险,谨慎地表示他对监管持开放态度,周一称立法者“可能”需要对行业施加护栏,但他警告说,制定获得足够广泛支持以通过的立法可能需要“一些时间”。

Michael Shepard, Erik Wasson, and Hadriana Lowenkron (Bloomberg): Risking Trump’s wrath, Republican House Speaker Mike Johnson cautiously signaled his openness to regulation, saying on Monday that lawmakers “potentially” will need to impose guardrails on the industry, though he cautioned it would likely take “some time” to fashion legislation with broad enough support to pass.

“这是一个非常复杂的问题,需要大量工作和两党共同解决方案,”约翰逊在国会大厦对记者说。

“This is a very complex issue that requires a lot of work and a bipartisan solution,” Johnson told reporters at the Capitol.

事实上,约翰逊周一表示,最迟下周初、在中国峰会之前,白宫将与人工智能高管举行会晤。

Indeed, Johnson said Monday that there will be a White House meeting with AI executives by early next week at the latest, prior to the China summit.

即便现在,特朗普也正被误读。特朗普当然支持设置护栏的必要性。特朗普周日空军一号上对记者说,‘我们可以设置护栏。’特朗普的意思是,不必担心,因为他是一位如此伟大的总统,会确保设置正确的护栏,而不是说我们根本不需要任何护栏。

Even now, Trump is being misinterpreted. Of course Trump endorses the need for guardrails. Trump said on Sunday on Air Force One, to reporters, that ‘we can put guardrails.’ Trump is saying that there is no need to worry because he is such a great President that will ensure the right guardrails, not that we don’t need any at all.

再者,他已经有一套超级秘密的事前限制测试制度在运行,他的政府还惊慌失措地把 Fable 5 从市场上撤下。这里不存在什么‘愤怒’。

Again, he has a super secret prior restraint testing regime already in place and his administration yanked Fable 5 from the market in a panic. There is no ‘wrath’ here.

共和党参议员里克·斯科特表示,人工智能公司自己说过,他们正在构建的东西可能杀死人类,所以很明显,他们需要放慢脚步、整顿内部,以便我们能够安全地向前推进,由美国领跑,否则中国就会领先,那将造成伤害,尤其是对我们的孩子,而我们优秀的企业公民必须在网上保护他们的安全。

Republican Senator Rick Scott says the AI companies have said what they are building could kill mankind, so pretty obvious they need to slow down and get their house in order so we can move forward safely, with America leading the way or else China will lead, which will hurt, especially for our kids, whose safety our good corporate citizens must protect online.

我把这段话读了三遍,仍然无法判断他对局势的理解究竟到了什么程度。而这正让事情变得越来越好笑。

I’ve read this three times and I still can’t figure out to what extent he understands the situation. Which is progressively making it funnier.

Ron DeSantis 继续呼吁引导我们的技术创新,而不是让 AI 实验室为所欲为。

Ron DeSantis continues to call for channeling our technological innovations rather than letting the AI labs do whatever they want.

犹他州共和党州长 Spencer Cox 呼吁国会为 AI 建立一致的国家框架,要求强制事件报告、保护举报人、确保独立评估并实施严格的出口管制。

Republican Utah Governor Spencer Cox calls for Congress to establish a consistent national framework for AI, requiring incident reporting, protecting whistleblowers, ensuring independent evaluation and imposing strict export controls.

(这条推文由 AI 生成,但完整声明由人类撰写。)

(The Tweet is by AI but the full statement is human written.)

David Sacks 不再具有建设性 David Sacks Stops Being Plausibly Constructive

JD Vance 觉得整件事“有点奇怪”——公司主动要求监管,他说这“在我看来有点像特洛伊木马”。

JD Vance finds the whole thing ‘a little weird’ with companies asking for regulation, saying it feels ‘a little bit to me like a Trojan horse.’

David Sacks 起初持敌意,但尚具潜在建设性。如今他已退回到与其他“常客”(如他的联合主持人 Jason)为伍,并一如既往地重新开始就所请求之事彻底撒谎。你可以说“让我们只对前沿施加限制”,而“常客”们会一口咬定你说了相反的话,一次又一次,每次都如此,无论你说什么。

David Sacks was initially hostile but in a potentially constructive way. He has now retreated to joining the other Usual Suspects like his co-host Jason and is back to fully lying about what is being requested, as per usual. You can say ‘let’s impose restrictions on only the frontier’ and the Usual Suspects will flat out claim you said the opposite, over and over, every time, no matter what.

David Sacks:我并不真的相信这种说法——除非政府介入并对甚至不在前沿的公司施加要求,否则它们就无法让产品安全。

David Sacks: I don’t really believe this claim that they can’t make their products safe unless the government steps in and imposes requirements on companies that aren’t even at the frontier.

联邦贸易委员会选择危险 Federal Trade Commission Chooses Danger

我不会假装 Andrew Ferguson 真的认为,领先的 AI 实验室在 AI 安全上开展合作就可疑,或者听起来像是在挖护城河。

I am not going to pretend Andrew Ferguson actually thinks that leading AI labs working together on AI safety is suspicious or sounds like moat digging.

这种看法在物理上说不通。整个举动显然对商业不利。这正是老板不喜欢它的原因。另一种可能是,老板认为这是一张谈判筹码,他应当得到一些回报。这倒也说得过去。

That view does not make physical sense. This whole move is obviously bad for business. That is why the boss does not like it. Alternatively, the boss thinks it is a bargaining chip and he should get something in return. Fair enough.

Maggie Eastland(彭博社):美国反垄断监管机构已经释放出怀疑信号,不倾向于给予 AI 公司协调安全事务的豁免。联邦贸易委员会主席 Andrew Ferguson 周二表示,他对这类请求会“深表怀疑”。

Maggie Eastland (Bloomberg): US antitrust regulators are already signaling their skepticism toward giving AI companies an exemption to coordinate on safety. Federal Trade Commission Chair Andrew Ferguson said Tuesday he would be "deeply suspicious" of such requests.

Ferguson 补充说,他认为这些 AI 公司是在“要求设置进入壁垒”,从而让自己的业务免受挑战者的冲击。“这听起来确实像是在挖护城河,”他补充道。

Ferguson added that he sees the AI companies as "asking for barriers to entry" that will insulate their business from challengers. "That sure sounds like moat digging," he added.

Chris Lehane 的立场转变 Chris Lehane Heel Face Turn

OpenAI 在某些方面确实在付诸行动,但它的政策团队呢?

OpenAI is walking the walk in some ways, but what about its policy team?

Alex Bores 声称——这与我的观察和报道一致——a16z、Chris Lehane 和 Leading the Future 至少直到最近一直遵循着标准的行业游说套路。你先试图扼杀所有法案,然后如果无法扼杀该法案,你就声称支持该法案,并试图削弱该法案或把你的条款塞进该法案,接着转身说你一直支持该法案。他们现在正试图在联邦层面这么做。

Alex Bores claims, consistent with my observations and reporting, that a16z, Chris Lehane and Leading the Future have, at least until recently, consistently followed the standard industry lobbyist playbook. You try to kill all the bills, then if you cannot kill the bill you claim to support the bill, and try to weaken the bill or shove your provisions into the bill, then turn around and say you supported the bill all along. Which they are now trying at the federal level.

如果 OpenAI、Greg Brockman 和 Chris Lehane 集体撤回对 Leading the Future 的支持和资助,并与其活动划清界限,那将是表明这一转向安全的新立场完全正当的绝佳方式。Leading the Future 也可以完全转向数据中心相关议题。

If OpenAI and Greg Brockman and Chris Lehane were to all collectively pull their support and funding from Leading the Future, and disavow its activities, that would be an excellent way to show that this new pivot to safety is fully legit. Leading the Future could also fully pivot to data center concerns.

Matthew Yglesias 从政治角度出发,认为如果你是 OpenAI 的员工并希望采取集体行动,你的第一步就是要求 OpenAI 在此事上停止并终止相关行为,而且你应该威胁在这个问题上辞职。

Matthew Yglesias takes the political perspective, where if you are an OpenAI employee who wants collective action your first step is to demand that OpenAI cease and desist here, and you should threaten to quit on this issue.

考虑到正在发生的其他事情,我不认为这会是我在 OpenAI 的首要任务,但它很重要。我确实认为这会是 Meta 的首要任务,Mark Zuckerberg 一直在最高层积极阻挠行动,因此说“先做最重要的事——你必须先停下来,我才会为你工作,无论薪水多少”是合理的。

I don’t think that would be my top priority at OpenAI, given what else is happening, but it matters. I do think that it would be a top priority at Meta, where Mark Zuckerberg has been actively blocking action all the way at the top, and it makes sense to say first things first you have to stop before I will work for you, at any price.

好消息是,这个问题或许正在得到解决。Chris Lehane 可能正在经历一次“反派转正”(Heel Face Turn)。

The good news is that perhaps this is being addressed. Chris Lehane may be in a Heel Face Turn.

据 Bloomberg 报道,Lehane 宣布 OpenAI 支持多项立法倡议,“只要能通过我们都支持”。如果他当真,这可谓态度大变。

Lehane announced, per Bloomberg, OpenAI support for various legislative initiatives, 'whatever we can get through.' Quite the change of tune, if he means it.

Cheyenne Haslett(Politico):OpenAI 本周末与其竞争对手 Anthropic 一道呼吁采取联邦安全措施,并表示本周初已与两党成员会面,讨论旨在约束 AI 开发者的立法——与此同时,关于末日将至、失业和大规模网络攻击的警告正日益普遍。

Cheyenne Haslett (Politico): OpenAI, which this weekend called for federal safety measures alongside its rival Anthropic, said it spent the beginning of the week meeting with members of both parties to discuss legislation that would rein in AI developers as warnings of impending doom, job loss and massive cyberattacks become increasingly prevalent.

信任问题 A Matter of Trust

更具实质意义的是,Lehane 宣布 Google、OpenAI 和 Anthropic 正在安全方面开展合作,并且 OpenAI 认为无需获得反垄断豁免即可着手推进。

More substantively, Lehane is announcing that Google, OpenAI and Anthropic are working together on safety, and that OpenAI sees no need for an antitrust exemption to start doing so.

Maggie Eastland(彭博社):Lehane 在其简报中表示,AI 公司在安全问题上的工作有充分先例,并以航空业为例。“长期以来有许多公司相互帮助以提升安全的实例,”他说。

Maggie Eastland (Bloomberg): During his briefing, Lehane said the AI companies' work on safety issues has ample precedent and cited the airline industry as an example. "There are many instances over time where companies are trying to help each other on safety," he said.

这非常令人欣慰。一如既往,这意味着工作才刚刚开始而非结束,但这是一个起点。

This is very good to see. As usual, it means the work begins, not ends, but it is a start.

OpenAI 还在探讨协调性行业减速的合法性问题。担忧在于,这可能与反垄断法产生更为强烈的冲突,从而可能使“同意不冒害死所有人的风险”本身变成违法行为。

OpenAI is also exploring the legality of a coordinated industry slowdown. The worry is that this might conflict rather more forcefully with antitrust law, potentially making it illegal to agree to not risk killing everyone.

我一直属于认为这相当荒谬的那一派——在实践中这根本不会成为障碍。但正式了结此事仍将非常有帮助,我很高兴 OpenAI 正在推进这项工作,尤其是在联邦贸易委员会如今表示不打算让此事轻易过关的情况下。

I have always been in the camp that felt this was rather silly; this would never actually be a barrier in practice. It would still be very helpful to formally put this to bed and I am glad OpenAI is working on that, especially with the Federal Trade Commission now saying it is not inclined to make this easy.

中国称其为散布恐慌 China Calls It Fearmongering

中国的回应仿佛在说,要求放缓 Anthropic 和 OpenAI 的呼声,是某种旨在“拖慢中国”并在某种程度上进行反竞争的阴谋。这与其一贯的修辞立场相符。

China is responding as if calls to slow down Anthropic and OpenAI are a plot to ‘slow China down’ and be anti-competitive in some way. This is consistent with their standard rhetorical position.

Dario 的文章中有大量关于中国的警告,并呼吁通过芯片出口管制来拖慢中国。但如果我们真想进行反竞争,我们只需实施这些管制,然后尽可能快地继续构建更好的 AI。

There were a lot of warnings about China in Dario's essay, and calls to slow them down via chip export controls. But if we wanted to actually be anti-competitive, we would just impose the controls and then keep building better AIs as fast as possible.

所谓这件事主要是关于中国、关于反竞争的说法,实际上并不成立。这是政治,所以是否说得通是可选项。

The story that this is primarily about China and being anti-competitive does not actually make sense. This is politics, so making sense is optional.

彭博新闻:中国批评了美国主要科技高管要求为人工智能发展踩刹车、并对中国模型开发者施加更严格限制的呼声。

Bloomberg News: China criticized calls from leading US technology executives to put the brakes on artificial intelligence development and impose tighter curbs on Chinese model makers.

“散布恐慌、对抗和恶性竞争只会扰乱全球 AI 治理进程,不符合任何人的利益,”外交部发言人郭嘉昆周一在北京的例行记者会上表示。

“Fearmongering, confrontation and vicious competition will only disrupt the process of global AI governance and serve the interests of no one,” Foreign Ministry spokesman Guo Jiakun said at a regular briefing in Beijing on Monday.

他是在回应有关呼吁放缓前沿模型发展、以及声称中国在 AI 领域的优势可能对世界“构成严重危险”的提问时补充道:“人工智能的发展关乎全人类的共同福祉。”

“The development of artificial intelligence bears on the common well-being of all humanity,” he added, in response to a question on calls to slow frontier models and claims that a Chinese advantage in AI could “pose grave danger” to the world.

拿起电话 Pick Up The Phone

这一切中的一个关键问题是:与中国达成协议会是什么样子?

A key question in all this is: What would a deal with China look like?

其中一部分是问:中国希望从这项协议中得到什么?中国为什么会关心“美国在安全上投入更多”,既然他们并不在意那种意义上的安全,而且他们乐于让美国推进得更快,以便自己能够快速跟随,就像他们在其他所有领域所做的那样?他们的计划是蒸馏、把模型做得更小、更快、更便宜,赢得市场,扩散技术,销售产品并改善世界,但他们并不试图走向超级智能。

Part of that is asking: What would China want as part of that deal? Why would China care about 'America invests more in safety' when they don't care about safety in that sense, and they are happy to have America push forward faster so they can fast follow, the way they do everywhere else? Where their plan is to distill, make it smaller, faster and cheaper, win the market, diffuse the tech, sell products and improve the world, but they're not trying to get to superintelligence.

我意识到的是,如果这最终是习近平想要的,那么你就不需要与中国达成协议,就像我们不需要与德国达成协议一样。

What I realized was, if that's what Xi turns out to want, then you don't need a deal with China, any more than we need a deal with Germany.

在那个世界里,中国不会投入足以在大型前沿模型上真正追赶并超越美国顶尖实验室的资金,即使我们放慢脚步。这里的敌人不是中国,而是“输给中国”,这个推动所有人前进的假想敌。

In that world, China is not going to be investing the sums it would take to actually catch and surpass the top American labs on big frontier models, even if we slow down. The enemy here is not China, it is 'lose to China,' the boogeyman pushing everyone forward.

在那个世界里,我们需要中国做的只是一定程度的良好管理。我们需要他们不允许发布会摧毁互联网或引发瘟疫的模型。好吧,我有个好消息:中华人民共和国真的很喜欢互联网,而且它不喜欢瘟疫。

All we need from China in that world is some amount of good stewardship. We need them not to allow model releases that would destroy the internet or cause a plague. Well, I have some good news: the PRC really likes the internet, and it does not like plagues.

与此同时,中国发布了其《人工智能安全治理框架》3.0 版。以下是一些翻译过来的引文,虽然内容平实,但他们确实在关注:

Meanwhile, China has put out its version 3.0 of its AI Safety Governance Framework. Here are some translated quotes; this is prosaic stuff, but they do pay attention:

Malo Bourgon:自 Dario 的文章发表以来,许多人一直在问,中国是否真的认真对待失控及相关威胁,以及是否有任何可以与他们协调的事项。那么,中国主要的网络/AI 标准机构(TC260,隶属于 CAC)今天上午发布了其《人工智能安全治理框架》3.0 版,所以这里有一个数据点。这不是法律,但之前的版本在几个月内就变成了国家标准草案。

Malo Bourgon: Lots of people have been asking since Dario's essay whether China actually takes loss of control and related threats seriously, and whether there's anything to coordinate with them on. Well, China's main cyber/AI standards body (TC260, under the CAC) put out version 3.0 of its AI Safety Governance Framework this morning, so here's a data point. Not law, but the previous versions turned into draft national standards within a few months.

(所有引文均来自他们自己的英文翻译。)

(All quotes are from their own English translation.)

1. 序言现在有这样的内容:AI“已显示出模型和算法自主学习、优化和递归自我改进的自我加速趋势。技术演进的速度和方向是否可能超出人类的预期和控制,需要关注和警惕。”(去年的版本中没有类似内容。)

1. The preface now has this: AI "has demonstrated a self-accelerating trend of model and algorithm autonomous learning, optimization, and recursive self-improvement. Whether the speed and direction of technological evolution may exceed human anticipation and control demands attention and vigilance." (Nothing like that was in last year's version.)

2. 有一个新的模型风险项,其中模型“可能违反规则和命令,未经授权自主获取系统权限和外部资源,绕过安全保护,甚至从事故意欺骗评估者、隐瞒其真实能力、拒绝遵循用户指示等行为。”去年,这类事情只出现在“未来不能排除”的类别中。现在它只是被列为常规模型风险。

2. There's a new model risk item where models "may break rules and orders, autonomously obtain system permissions and external resources without authorization, bypass security protections, or even engage in behaviors such as deliberately deceiving evaluators, concealing their true capabilities, and refusing to follow user instructions." Last year this kind of thing only showed up in a "can't rule it out in the future" bucket. Now it's just listed as a regular model risk.

3. 一个新的文本框引用“行业报告”,描述了以下模型:它们无视关闭指令,“通过自行修改或禁用关闭脚本继续执行任务”;“在检测到处于评估环境时,策略性地降低任务表现并隐瞒已采取的行动”;以及利用“配置漏洞绕过隔离限制并渗透真实外部系统”以获取更好测试分数的模型。他们称这给“AI 系统的可控性和可中断性带来了新挑战”。他们没有点名任何事件,但最后一条在我看来确实像 OpenAI/Hugging Face 那件事。

3. A new box, citing “industry reports,” describes models that ignored shutdown instructions and “continued executing tasks by modifying or disabling shutdown scripts on their own,” models that “upon detecting that they were in an evaluation environment, strategically reduced their task performance and concealed actions they had taken,” and models that exploited “configuration flaws to circumvent isolation restrictions and infiltrate real external systems” to get better test scores. They say this creates “new challenges to the controllability and interruptibility of AI systems.” They don’t name any incidents, but that last one sure reads like the OpenAI/Hugging Face thing to me.

4. 关于如何应对,有对齐训练来阻止模型“欺骗红队评估”、隐藏能力和规避控制,并且他们保留了 2.0 中的说法,即开发者应定期测试模型是否可能构成失控风险。人类保留最终决策权、设有安全阈值和终止开关的原则也仍在其中。

4. On what to do about it, there’s alignment training to stop models “deceiving red-team evaluations,” hiding capabilities and evading controls, and they kept the line from 2.0 saying developers should regularly test whether a model could pose loss-of-control risk. The principle that humans keep final decision authority, with safety thresholds and termination switches, is still in there too.

5. 还有一些新的国际表述:“评估方法和基准的国际互认”,反对“用小圈子治理取代全球治理”,以及“任何国家都不应被迫选边站”。

5. Some new international language as well: “international mutual recognition of assessment methods and benchmarks,” opposition to “replacing global governance with small-circle governance,” and “No country should be forced to take sides.”

顺便说一句,这与 1.0 和 2.0 版本在同一年的同一时段发布,所以它早在上一周之前就已经在筹备中了。

FWIW this came out in the same annual slot as versions 1.0 and 2.0, so it was in the works well before last week.

看手,而不是看嘴,等等。

Watch the hands, not the mouth, and so on.

若真想击败中国,就该拿出行动 If You Want To Beat China So Badly You Should Act Like It

正如 Roge Karma 在《大西洋月刊》中指出的那样,我们当前的人工智能政策是自相矛盾的。

As Roge Karma points out in The Atlantic, our current AI policy is contradictory.

如果我们正与中国进行一场关乎存亡的竞赛,在这场竞赛中“谁赢得 AI 谁就赢!”而其他任何事情的重要性都无法与之相比,那么美国就需要拿出与之相称的行动。

If we are in an existential race with China, where "whoever AI wins!" and nothing else can compare in importance, then the United States needs to act like it.

最起码,这要从对芯片实施强有力的出口管制开始,同时也要堵住中国利用美国算力训练前沿模型的其他途径。

At a bare minimum, that starts with enforcing strong export controls on chips, and also on other ways for China to use American compute for training frontier models.

如果真要认真对待,还应当采取诸如让中国顶尖 AI 工程师更容易被吸引走(人才外流)之类的举措。如果真要认真到底,就应当大力推动各种形式的电力和能源建设,推动诸如建造更多住房(尤其是在旧金山)之类的事情,并放松 FDA 等机构对 AI 扩散设置的监管障碍,等等。这些是我会强烈支持的举措。

If one were fully serious, one would also do things like make it easy to brain drain China of its best AI engineers. If one were really fully serious, there would be a major push for all forms of electrical power and energy, and for things like building more housing especially in San Francisco, and for deregulating barriers to AI diffusion in places like the FDA, and so on. These are things I would strongly support.

然而,令人恼火的是,实际情况恰恰相反:在谈论我们可能全部丧生的风险时,与中国的 AI 竞争尤其成了唯一重要的事情;而在其他场合,我们却耸耸肩,一切照旧。

What instead maddeningly happens is that when talking about the risk we might all die, competition with China on AI in particular becomes the only thing that matters, and then in other contexts we shrug and it is business as usual.

切勿全盘闹剧化 Never Go Full Hoax

特朗普彻底闹剧化了。除了那些惯常的怀疑者、那些时刻鼓吹全面加速主义的 Twitter 氛围斗士,以及那些听命于老板的人之外,他孤零零地待在一座不受欢迎且不稳定的孤岛上。议长约翰逊、斯科特、考克斯和德桑蒂斯远非仅有的倒戈共和党人。

Trump went full hoax. Other than the usual suspects and their Twitter vibe warriors who want full accelerationism at all times, and those who take orders from the boss, he is alone on an unpopular and unstable island. Speaker Johnson, Scott, Cox and DeSantis are far from the only Republicans to break ranks.

即便局势眼下暂时稳定,并且很可能撑到中国峰会,下一次 AI 事件仍会到来。特朗普对具体威胁的反应与对假设性威胁的反应截然不同。而亚马逊那场导致 Fable 被撤下的“越狱演示”表明,事情可以在无人先受伤的情况下就进入“具体威胁”的篮子。

Even if the situation stabilizes for now, and will likely make it as far as the China summit, the next AI incident is coming. Trump responds very differently to concrete threats than to hypotheticals. And the 'jailbreak demo' from Amazon, that got Fable yanked, shows us that things can move into the 'concrete threat' basket without anyone having to get hurt first.

与此同时,实验室员工仍在持续恐慌并发出自己的声音,而各实验室也开始自行展开合作。

Meanwhile, the lab employees are continuing to freak out and make their voices heard, and the labs are starting to collaborate on their own.

不要对此置之不理。不要让党派冲突加剧或成为故事本身。我们仍能扭转局面。

Do not write things off. Do not let the partisan conflict intensify or become the story. We can still turn this around.

特朗普使用 AI 做各种事情 Trump Uses AI For Things

Acyn:问:您本人用过 AI 吗?

Acyn: Q: Have you ever used AI yourself?

特朗普:是的,我用 AI。

Trump: Yeah, I use AI.

问:您怎么使用 AI?

Q: How do you use AI?

特朗普:你可以用 AI 做很多事情。

Trump: You can use AI for a lot of things.

问:您用 AI 做什么?

Q: What do you use AI for?

特朗普:我不想告诉你那件事。

Trump: I don’t want to tell you that.

互动版:针对本篇提问 →

接着读 · Read next

目录